By: Savannah Love Chadee

Thanksgiving has traditionally been a time for families and friends to come together, share a meal, and reflect on what they appreciate. Since its development into an annually observed national holiday, the celebration has carried a meaning that extends beyond food and family gatherings. According to the National Archives, President George Washington proclaimed November 26, 1789, as a national day of Thanksgiving under the new Constitution. President Abraham Lincoln later proclaimed a national Thanksgiving observance in 1863, and Congress established the fourth Thursday in November as the federal holiday in 1941. However, as American traditions have changed, so has the way people experience the holiday.
In my opinion, Thanksgiving has gradually become overshadowed by the commercial activities that surround it, raising the question of whether Americans are spending more time preparing for holiday sales than appreciating the purpose of the celebration. The growing popularity of Black Friday and the holiday shopping season has changed the atmosphere surrounding Thanksgiving. What was once primarily an opportunity to gather and express gratitude now shares the spotlight with advertisements, shopping promotions and retailers competing for consumers’ attention. A 2023 commentary published by Liberty Champion examines just how consumer culture has been influencing the meaning of Thanksgiving.
Whereas shopping has become a familiar part of the holiday weekend, I believe it is worth considering whether these commercial traditions are beginning to receive more attention than the values Thanksgiving was originally intended to represent. This connection between Thanksgiving and commercial interests is not entirely new. According to the National Archives, President Franklin D. Roosevelt moved Thanksgiving one week earlier in 1939 to extend the Christmas shopping season and encourage economic activity during the Great Depression. This decision was controversial, with several states refusing to follow the new date.
In 1941, Congress established Thanksgiving as the fourth Thursday in November. This historical example demonstrates that the relationship between the holiday and the retail industry has existed for generations. The influence of holiday shopping has continued to grow as advertising and consumer spending have become increasingly connected to American holiday traditions. Today, Black Friday has developed into one of the busiest shopping periods of the year. According to the National Retail Federation, an estimated 202.9 million consumers shopped during the five-day period from Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday in 2025.
Although this figure represents shopping activity across the entire holiday weekend rather than Thanksgiving Day alone, it illustrates just how significant holiday shopping has become in American culture. These numbers do not necessarily mean Americans have become less grateful, but they do demonstrate how much attention and participation the retail industry receives during a holiday centered on appreciation and togetherness. In my view, this growing emphasis on consumer spending deserves more consideration.
The pressure to participate in holiday spending can also take away from what Thanksgiving is supposed to symbolize. Families may feel obligated to purchase expensive gifts, prepare elaborate meals, or decorate their homes to meet expectations created by advertising and popular culture. For households already managing tight budgets, these expectations can create additional financial stress during a season that is supposed to bring people together. Thanksgiving should not become another occasion where people feel pressured to spend money to demonstrate their appreciation for others.
Another factor contributing to this shift is the influence of advertising and social media. As the holiday season approaches, consumers are constantly exposed to online advertisements, promotional campaigns, gift guides, and posts showcasing expensive purchases. These images can create unrealistic expectations about what a successful holiday celebration should look like. People may begin comparing their own celebrations to what they see online, placing greater importance on material possessions rather than personal experiences.
Instead of focusing on preparing a meal with loved ones or spending quality time together, the emphasis can shift toward creating the appearance of a perfect holiday. For college students and young adults especially, holiday spending can create pressure to purchase gifts for friends, partners, and family members while managing their own expenses. Gift exchanges and holiday celebrations should not depend on someone’s ability to afford expensive presents. A thoughtful gesture or simply spending time with someone can be just as meaningful.
This issue also has a connection to communities throughout South Jersey. While retailers encourage consumers to spend during the holiday season, local organizations and food assistance programs remind us that not everyone has the same financial opportunities to celebrate. For example, the Food Bank of South Jersey works with community partners through Burlington, Camden, Gloucester, and Salem counties to help provide food to individuals and families experiencing food insecurity. Its work highlights another way residents can participate in the holiday season: by supporting neighbors who may need additional assistance.
Rather than measuring the success of Thanksgiving by how much money is spent, South Jersey residents can demonstrate appreciation by supporting local food drives, donating groceries, volunteering, or helping families in their communities. These actions can make a meaningful difference while reinforcing the importance of giving back. Supporting local businesses and farmers can also be a positive way to contribute to the regional community, especially during a season when many small businesses depend on consumer support. Shopping locally can be meaningful, but it should complement the spirit of Thanksgiving rather than replace it.
This does not mean shopping or exchanging gifts during the holiday season is necessarily a bad thing. Supporting small businesses, purchasing thoughtful gifts, and taking advantage of affordable deals can all be enjoyable parts of celebrating. Moreover, these activities should not become more than the relationships and traditions that make the holiday special.
Ultimately, Thanksgiving should be about more than what we purchase during holiday sales. It should be an opportunity to appreciate our loved ones, our communities, and the shared experiences that bring people together. As the holiday shopping season continues to grow, Americans should make an effort to recognize the difference between participating in consumer traditions and genuinely expressing gratitude. Especially here in South Jersey, giving back to our communities can be just as important as gathering around the dinner table. After all, gratitude should not be measured by how much money someone spends, but by the appreciation they show for the people and experiences in their lives.
- Has Thanksgiving Become More About Shopping Than Giving Thanks?
- $450 Million Film Studio Development Proposed for Former Sony Site in Pitman
- Why I Believe Villanova Shouldn’t Leave the Big 5
This article was produced as part of Follow South Jersey’s student journalism program, which provides aspiring journalists with practical experience in professional news reporting and writing.



