Why I Believe Villanova Shouldn’t Leave the Big 5

By: Malachi Morton

Philadelphia Inquirer Connor Smith

College basketball has always been about more than just winning games. It is about rivalries, tradition, school pride and giving fans something to look forward to every season. That is why I believe Villanova should not be stepping away from the Philadelphia Big 5 men’s basketball competition beginning with the 2027–28 season. The Big 5 has been a major part of Philadelphia basketball for more than 70 years, and Villanova has been one of the biggest names associated with it. While college athletics continues to change and schools are looking for ways to make more money and improve their programs, I think some traditions are too important to walk away from. Villanova leaving the Big 5 is bigger than just one basketball program changing its schedule. It is taking away a rivalry that has helped define college basketball in the Philadelphia area, including for fans throughout South Jersey.

The Philadelphia Big 5 was established in 1955 with five schools: Villanova, Temple, Saint Joseph’s, La Salle and the University of Pennsylvania. Drexel later joined the competition in 2023, making it a six-school competition. For decades, these schools competed against each other for city bragging rights, creating matchups that meant something to players, students and fans. Villanova has been one of the most successful programs in the history of the competition, winning more Big 5 titles than any other school. That kind of history is exactly why I believe the Wildcats should continue being part of it.

One of the biggest reasons behind this decision is the changing business side of college basketball. Villanova wanted a different scheduling arrangement that would give the program more home games and opportunities to generate revenue. Head coach Kevin Willard has explained that playing a 20-game Big East schedule makes it difficult to add additional road games against other programs. Villanova also believes that playing certain Big 5 games on the road takes away opportunities to bring in revenue from home games. I understand that college basketball is a business, and schools have to make decisions that help their programs financially. However, I don’t think leaving the Big 5 is the right answer. Sometimes schools have to look beyond ticket sales and scheduling and understand what their programs mean to the communities around them.

Another thing that makes this situation interesting is how much college sports have changed over the last few years. NIL, the transfer portal, conference realignment and revenue sharing have completely changed how athletic departments operate. Schools are now competing for players, sponsors and money in ways that were not as common years ago. Villanova is a program that wants to compete for Big East championships and make deep runs in the NCAA Tournament. I understand that the Wildcats want every advantage possible, but I believe schools can still compete at a high level without giving up the rivalries that helped build their programs. The Big 5 represents something much bigger than a few games on the calendar.

For South Jersey, this decision matters more than people might realize. Philadelphia sports have a huge following throughout South Jersey, and college basketball is another part of that connection. Whether someone grew up watching Villanova, Temple or Saint Joseph’s, these matchups give fans a reason to support their schools and represent their area. Villanova is not just another college basketball program to many fans in this region. It is a program that people have followed for generations. For people living in towns like Glassboro, Deptford, Washington Township and other parts of South Jersey, Philadelphia basketball is part of the sports culture. Many fans travel into Philadelphia to watch games, follow the teams throughout the season and support their favorite programs. These rivalries give those fans something to look forward to every year.

As someone who attends Rowan University, I also think about the importance of college sports and what they mean to students. College athletics brings students, alumni and entire communities together. Whether it is supporting your school’s basketball team, attending a football game or watching a rivalry matchup, there is something special about representing a school. Rowan and other colleges throughout South Jersey have their own athletic traditions, and those traditions help create school pride. That is why I think it is important for bigger programs like Villanova to recognize the impact they have beyond their own campus. The Big 5 gives people throughout the region an opportunity to connect with college basketball, even if they are not students at one of those universities.

The decision has also received criticism from people who have been connected to the Big 5 for years. According to reporting by The Philadelphia Inquirer, former longtime college basketball coach Fran Dunphy expressed disappointment about Villanova no longer being part of the men’s competition. Dunphy has coached at Penn, Temple and La Salle, giving him a unique perspective on what the rivalry means to Philadelphia basketball. He believes the schools should continue working together to keep the spirit of the Big 5 alive. When former coaches and people who helped build these programs are disappointed about the decision, it shows that this is not just about scheduling games. It is about protecting something that has been part of the city’s identity for generations.

There is also the question of what the Big 5 will look like moving forward. Beginning in the 2027–28 season, Drexel, La Salle, Penn, Saint Joseph’s and Temple plan to return to a full round-robin schedule featuring home and away games. The current Big 5 Classic tripleheader at Xfinity Mobile Arena will also end in its current format after the December 2026 event. There is still a possibility that the schools could bring back a one-day event in the future, but the current setup will not continue. The five remaining schools have made it clear that they want to preserve the tradition, even without Villanova. While that is good news for the future of the competition, it is still disappointing that one of the most successful programs in Big 5 history will no longer be part of the men’s series.

I also think Villanova has to consider what it means for its fans. Not every fan is looking at college basketball from a business perspective. Some people just want to see their favorite team play against the schools they have competed against for decades. A Villanova game against Temple or Saint Joseph’s feels different because of the history between those schools. You can schedule games against other programs across the country, but you cannot automatically recreate the history and excitement that comes with a rivalry that has lasted more than 70 years.

At the end of the day, I believe Villanova should stay in the Big 5 because traditions like this are what make college basketball special. I understand that the business side of college athletics is changing and that schools have to make decisions that are best for their programs. However, I don’t think every decision should come down to money, scheduling or how many home games a team can play. Villanova has played such an important role in building the Big 5 into what it is today. The Philadelphia and South Jersey communities deserve to continue seeing these matchups, and the players deserve the opportunity to be part of a rivalry that has meant so much to college basketball. College sports will continue to change, but that does not mean every tradition needs to change with it. Sometimes the best thing a program can do is remember what made it special in the first place.


This article was produced as part of Follow South Jersey’s student journalism program, which provides aspiring journalists with practical experience in professional news reporting and writing.